Hey Jelle, I like the clarity and separation in your mix - Brian went for “Epic” and “glue” over clarity.
One thing I did note was that your mix is a little on the harsh side in the 5-8k region. The transients are a little on the spiky side. I think if you could pull them back a bit things might glue together a little more and make for a more pleasant listen overall.
I think my main issue really is with the vocals not having any reverb/delay. I hesitate to elaborate further, because that may just fix everything that I had a problem with. I’m not super technical when it comes to picking out what’s wrong.
Nicely done. I would like a little more space in the mix. i think part of it the lack of the low mids is making it thin and almost brought to a point giving off the vibe that it is not that big a song.
Nicely done, Jelle. Love the lead’s voice, BTW. Nice scream vocals! All instruments come thru clearly. One thought is that the high hats sound a little too compressed to me. Maybe the attack is too short cuz the transients don’t come thru enough (esp on the verses). Just doesn’t sound right. But then again, what do I know! Just learning about these things myself.
Thanks mate A soon I do a revision, I’m going to do that and share the result.
Ok, I’ll check it across all tracks, fix the cymbals, and see if thats enough to tame them
Thanks mate! Would do you mean with the space in the mix part? Any speciffic parts or instruments you would suggest keeping this suggestion in mind? Because in the first reaction of @ColdRoomStudio he made the argument that Brians mix was more epic, “glued” then mine, so I would think there is more space in my mix already, or am I seing what you’re suggestion the wrong way ?
I’m gonna check my last edits to the bass track, and see if I overdid it. I don’t realy have a thin sound on my system though, but it could be because of that I overdid it. We’ll see after the revised version
Weird I only have compression on the fx channel of the drums I’ll have a look at it though. Might be just the volume of the hihat track thats causing this.
Join the club mate haha
Just to be sure, its not me found the tracks online.
Sounds great! Few comments (at least stuff that hasn’t been mentioned I think):
when comparing against Brian’s mix, yours has a lot less midrange info… very “scooped” sound. While I know that’s a mixing decision that you’ve made and is a preference thing, my preference tends to like some more of the mids in there (but not necessarily as much as Brian’s). I’m listening on headphones so I don’t want to throw specific frequency ranges out there… I may revisit once I get home in front of monitors.
I think the guitars need more “power”, and I have a feeling a lot of it would come from adding some of that mid goodness that I mentioned above back to them. as well as maybe pushing them up slightly in the mix, at least in the choruses to give them a nice little lift.
bass guitar sounds pretty badass… I haven’t seen the raw tracks on this one so I don’t know if it came with that tone, but I prefer the way you mixed it over Brian’s.
yeah sorry i should have been more specific. I feel like it is all around the center and i just found it lacking in low mids. I think that lack of mids is the big part of what is making it feel a bit thin. It is not much and it probably is just a taste thing.
Yeah, after mixing mine, and then going to check his, that was the first thing I noticed as well Maybe I went a bit to hard on the cut’s, and I think I would prefer a little bit more mids as well.
I’m gonna keep that in mind when I do a revision one of these days.
Thanks Was aiming for baddass haha. Actually it took a lot of processing. wasn’t a great DI track. At least not on the players part. Not terrible, but could be tighter
I did the 3 tracks approach. 1 DI track just for everything under 200Hz, 1 track with and amp for everything above 700Hz, and then another track like that, but then with a bass distortion in front of the amp, and also above 700Hz. I think even a bit higer. Then lots of compression and limmitting and more EQ until the meter almost stopped moving
None the less, I will take it into account with my revision thanks mate!
I used primarally Fabfilter plugins. The C2, Q2, MB, L, R2 and Saturn. A lot of saturn . Mostly just ‘warm tube’ saturation with some high and prescense boost. L1 and L2 from waves, and a little bit of the stock maximiser from cubase on the two bus.
I think the confusion comes in because the word “space” can mean different things in different contexts.
When we talk about frequency space, it is the opposite of glue because generally it means there is more separation between the different elements in the mix, and each can be heard more clearly.
On the other hand, talking about “space” in the mix referring to the ambient effects like reverb and delay, then this can have the opposite effect of frequency space - it can glue the mix together and make all the parts less distinct and separated. Delays especially can make a mix sound “bigger” and more “epic”
In Brian’s mix, he has a lot of ambient fx and more low mids. This both glues the mix together and adds to its sense of “epic-ness”.
Wow. what a difference! This is very nice. Sounds full and very “professional.” It creates more energy.
I love what you did here. And I like what you did with the drums. Very realistic. I’d bring them up more, though. In this genre drums are more prominent. I know you said you used Slate drums: are they played live with triggered samples, or are these loops? Very nice.
Sound on the guitars is excellent. Not familiar with Mercuriall reaxis. I use mainly S-Gear. These are sweet. Nicely played also.
And I LOVE the scream vox. IDK if I wanna say they could be a little louder, so much as maybe more automation. There are parts where they’re loud enough, and parts where not.
But don’t touch the guitars and bass, baby! They’re awesome. Don’t change anything with EQ either. You should feel really good about this mix! Thanks for sharing.